
One of the world's most well travelled, musically diverse and successful artists in Rock 'n' Roll, Elton John aka Reg Dwight has been a mainstay of Rock and Popular Music audiences in kind for 4 decades almost. After performing to a portentous crowd at the Troubadour in his first ever American show, Dwight received praise dubbing him the new musical talent and performer for his era.
In the wake of Rock 'n' Roll's most recent casualty list, including Janis Joplin, Jimi Hendrix and the breakup of The Beatles supergroup, people craved less and less the social activism which had charged Rock music of the 60's and instead looked to musicians to provide something new, something more individual, vibrant and artistic; "Elton John had somehow captured the zeitgeist of a new decade." (p. 238) Several things set Elton John apart from the previous decade's cohort, especially in regards to background, musical discipline and work ethic. Firstly, he was a suburban boy from the cosy Middle Class streets of Pinner, northwest of London. This in itself was not particularly remarkable, as many famous British musicians including John Lennon, Keith Moon and Mick Jagger had come from the suburbs, however unlike his predecessors who had rejected their suburban roots for inner city living, John revelled in and prided himself on his humble suburban roots. Secondly, he was not an amateur musician. By the time he had played his first show at the Troubadour in the US, John Lennon had over 10 years experience in the music business, having engaged in varied and musically diverse occupations working in all levels of the music industry itself. And into the present day, when charting Elton's progress, one can observe a veritable 9 lives in the business itself as Laing charts in his investigation of the man himself:
1. Classical Piano Prodigy
2. Pub pianist
3. Pop group member
4. Publisher's office boy
5. Backing musician
6. Songwriter
7. Session musician
8. Soundalike artist
9. Solo recording artist
As we can see, John comes from one of the most developed and musically diverse backgrounds of any performer today. Whereas many of the musicians of the 60's had simply picked up guitars, drums and were self-taught, John was trained in classical piano up to 8th grade before he even entered secondary school at age 11. Whilst it was this strong grounding in classic piano's artform which would inform his virutousity, it was his mother's love of pop music, especially the rock n roll of the 50's (Chuck Berry, Elvis Presley) which would ultimately decide his career direction in the music industry.
However Elton John's success is not only indicative of a shift in attitudes and perceptions of Rock music and a return to instrumentalism in the genre itself, but also of changing patterns in lifestyle, Rock audience demographics and the resegregation of music. At the time of his stardom being launched in the USA in 1970, John, a self-confessed suburbanite was hugely popular with a demographic which was more than ever, suburban in lifestyle and outlook, middle class to the core. Just as the backlash against the anti-war and civil rights movements of the 60's began to intensify and the idealism of the previous decades faded out, Elton John would come to dominate a music industry returning to the order and generic differentiation of popular music from yesteryear. What a curious coincidence.
Certainly Elton is a nonthreatening suggestion for any lover of rock wishing to steer clear of its activism and drug addled phase, however is such an explanation complete? Academics point to the resurgence of Elton John in a decade growing tired of the rock bands and supergroups of the 60's and certainly his appeal to older tastes in music, hearkening back to his love of popular music and rock 'n' roll in the 50's is a reflection of this. However it is not only his ideological differences, but also his musical background which play the biggest parts in creating his appeal.
Through his incorporation of jazz, blues and folk influences/styles in his work and the apparent readiness of a public wishing a return to good old Popular Music, but still craving a Rock vibe, Elton provided the perfect choice, a man who loved both popular music and Rock 'n' Roll, but whose social attitudes/performance were unthreatening and apolitical. Furthermore, his tastes and influences in music, as well as his training provided him with a virtuousity unshared by his counterparts and more appealing to a popular music audience which increasingly located itself in the suburban setting and hoped for a resurgence of the styles still popular in the 50's. By mixing old with new Elton was able to capture a Rock audience engaged in the mainstream and through his knowledge of the music industry and performance, has since been able to constantly reinvent himself to remain a popular artist through to the present day.
Therefore, In my opinion it is both a combination of his family background, musical training and social/cultural attitudes which gives John his appeal, combined with the favourable social conditions and apolitical cultural climate in which his music first emerged, perhaps even coming to typify the mood of the 70's themselves. Would he have enjoyed such success in the revolutionised world of the 70's which his hippy predecessors envisioned? Probably not. But that's not how the story went. How lucky for Elton.
Laing, D. (2008), 'Nine Lives in the Music Industry', Popular Music History, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 237-261







